Posts | Tags | Archive

Reducing Chromecast Idle Bandwidth

Google's Chromecast is a pretty useful device. It plugs into the HDMI port of a TV and allows users to "cast" content to it via a smartphone, Chrome browser, etc. This content is mostly assumed to be streaming services like Youtube, Spotify, or Netflix, but for someone who doesn't really buy into the whole cloud revolution like myself, it's still perfectly capable of playing local content as well.

The one downside of the Chromecast is that when it's not being used, instead of going into a low-power state and/or turning off the TV, it instead enters Ambient Mode. This shows some useful information overlaid on a changing backdrop of featured photos downloaded from Google Photos. The issue with this is that the images are high-resolution, not cached, and are continually being downloaded 24/7 even when the TV is turned off. Although I haven't personally measured it, the general consensus seems to be that it uses around 15GB of data per month from just being plugged in.

What I'll be going over here is reducing the data the Chromecast uses by configuring it to only download some tiny black 1x1 px images to use as a backdrop.

The short version

  • Make a tiny black PNG (pixel.png)
  • Make a slightly different tiny PNG to avoid deduplication (pixel_alt1.png)
  • Upload both to an album in Google Photos
  • Mark both images as favorites
  • Configure the Chromecast to only pull images from your specific album every 10 minutes

If you like details, keep reading...

Making a small image

I ended up creating a 1x1 solid black image in GIMP, saving it as a PNG, hacking out as much data as possible using a hex editor, then using pngcrush to attempt to optimize the data that was left.

As I was working on the PNG file, I used a small script based on the Python construct library to visualize the chunks and structure of it so I could figure out what to cut.

To install construct and download the example PNG specification:

1
2
3
4
python3 -m venv .venv
source .venv/bin/activate
pip install construct
wget "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/construct/construct/abd48c4892ceddc60c11d25f4a955573e2c61111/deprecated_gallery/png.py"

Create pngview.py:

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
import png  # the png spec downloaded above
import sys

with open(sys.argv[1], 'rb') as f:
    data = f.read()
    print("Size:", len(data), "bytes")
    print(png.png_file.parse(data))

Running it on the PNG exported from GIMP using the default settings gives:

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
$ ./pngview.py pixel.png
Size: 146 bytes
Container: 
    signature = b'\x89PNG\r\n\x1a\n' (total 8)
    image_header = Container: 
        length = 13
        signature = b'IHDR' (total 4)
        width = 1
        height = 1
        bit_depth = 8
        color_type = (enum) truecolor 2
        compression_method = (enum) deflate 0
        filter_method = (enum) adaptive5 0
        interlace_method = (enum) none 0
        crc = 2423739358
    chunks = ListContainer: 
        Container: 
            length = 9
            type = b'pHYs' (total 4)
            data = Container: 
                pixels_per_unit_x = 11811
                pixels_per_unit_y = 11811
                unit = (enum) meter 1
            crc = 2024095606
        Container: 
            length = 7
            type = b'tIME' (total 4)
            data = Container: 
                year = 2018
                month = 12
                day = 11
                hour = 5
                minute = 2
                second = 19
            crc = 904567710
        Container: 
            length = 25
            type = b'tEXt' (total 4)
            data = Container: 
                keyword = u'Comment' (total 7)
                text = b'Created with GIM'... (truncated, total 17)
            crc = 1468075543
        Container: 
            length = 12
            type = b'IDAT' (total 4)
            data = b'\x08\xd7c```\x00\x00\x00\x04\x00\x01' (total 12)
            crc = 657729290
        Container: 
            length = 0
            type = b'IEND' (total 4)
            data = None
            crc = 2923585666

After removing the unneeded pHYs, tIME, and tEXt chunks using a hex editor, it looks like this:

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
$ ./pngview.py pixel.png 
Size: 69 bytes
Container: 
    signature = b'\x89PNG\r\n\x1a\n' (total 8)
    image_header = Container: 
        length = 13
        signature = b'IHDR' (total 4)
        width = 1
        height = 1
        bit_depth = 8
        color_type = (enum) truecolor 2
        compression_method = (enum) deflate 0
        filter_method = (enum) adaptive5 0
        interlace_method = (enum) none 0
        crc = 2423739358
    chunks = ListContainer: 
        Container: 
            length = 12
            type = b'IDAT' (total 4)
            data = b'\x08\xd7c```\x00\x00\x00\x04\x00\x01' (total 12)
            crc = 657729290
        Container: 
            length = 0
            type = b'IEND' (total 4)
            data = None
            crc = 2923585666

At this point, all that's left to optimize is the image data itself. This is where pngcrush shines. After running pngcrush -brute -ow pixel.png we see:

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
$ ./pngview.py pixel.png
Size: 67 bytes
Container: 
    signature = b'\x89PNG\r\n\x1a\n' (total 8)
    image_header = Container: 
        length = 13
        signature = b'IHDR' (total 4)
        width = 1
        height = 1
        bit_depth = 8
        color_type = (enum) greyscale 0
        compression_method = (enum) deflate 0
        filter_method = (enum) adaptive5 0
        interlace_method = (enum) none 0
        crc = 981375829
    chunks = ListContainer: 
        Container: 
            length = 10
            type = b'IDAT' (total 4)
            data = b'\x08\x1dc`\x00\x00\x00\x02\x00\x01' (total 10)
            crc = 3486004709
        Container: 
            length = 0
            type = b'IEND' (total 4)
            data = None
            crc = 2923585666

The 2 byte savings in the data seem to have come from setting the color_type to greyscale instead of truecolor. To view what actually changed in the data, we can un-deflate it using Python:

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
>>> import zlib
>>> # before pngcrush (12 bytes)
>>> zlib.decompress(b'\x08\xd7c```\x00\x00\x00\x04\x00\x01')
b'\x00\x00\x00\x00'
>>> # after pngcrush (10 bytes)
>>> zlib.decompress(b'\x08\x1dc`\x00\x00\x00\x02\x00\x01')
b'\x00\x00'
>>>

This makes sense since, according to the PNG spec, when using truecolor, each pixel is an RGB triple, requiring 3 bytes. For greyscale, only a single byte representing luminance is needed. The first byte is the filtering method, which isn't relevant here since we only have a single pixel.

Interestingly enough, in both cases we would actually be much better off if we could opt to not use compression, but alas, the spec does not allow for anything except deflate.

But I digress, we now have a black 1x1 px PNG image that's just 67 bytes (pixel.png).

Generating multiple unique small images

So now we have the small PNG we want to display. Since the Chromecast's ambient mode requires at least 2 different images in an album to cycle through, all we need to to do is upload 2 copies of this PNG and we're done right? Almost.

Since Google Photos will automatically deduplicate uploaded images, we need to find a way to make the second image slightly different. Normally this would involve tweaking a comment or something, but in this case, the image has already been stripped down to its bare essentials.

My strategy was attempt to abuse the data compression to see if I could generate an image that compressed the same data into the same number of bytes, but differently. Fortunately, pngcrush can be told to use specific compression strategies (there are currently 177 of them). My hope is that at least one of these will achieve the same results, but in a different way. For starters we'll try the first 9:

1
2
3
for x in $(seq 9); do
    pngcrush -m "$x" pixel.png pixel_alt${x}.png;
done

A quick ls -l reveals that all of the pixel_alt*.png files are still 67 bytes. Now we just need to find one that has different data. sha1sum is the perfect utility for this:

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
$ sha1sum pixel.png pixel_alt*.png
d99a9d63b1cd9e4b3f823d4d03144ccd95328f48  pixel.png
7487dcce2b2bb81a442faf139b0a547bf070d5e2  pixel_alt1.png
7487dcce2b2bb81a442faf139b0a547bf070d5e2  pixel_alt2.png
7487dcce2b2bb81a442faf139b0a547bf070d5e2  pixel_alt3.png
c3ea09bfcfcb36ce22d3f19eacada359f3984ed1  pixel_alt4.png
c3ea09bfcfcb36ce22d3f19eacada359f3984ed1  pixel_alt5.png
c3ea09bfcfcb36ce22d3f19eacada359f3984ed1  pixel_alt6.png
c3ea09bfcfcb36ce22d3f19eacada359f3984ed1  pixel_alt7.png
c3ea09bfcfcb36ce22d3f19eacada359f3984ed1  pixel_alt8.png
d99a9d63b1cd9e4b3f823d4d03144ccd95328f48  pixel_alt9.png

pixel_alt1.png looks like a good candidate, let's see what changed:

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
$ diff <(./pngview.py pixel.png) <(./pngview.py pixel_alt1.png)
20,21c20,21
<             data = b'\x08\x1dc`\x00\x00\x00\x02\x00\x01' (total 10)
<             crc = 3486004709
---
>             data = b'\x08[c`\x00\x00\x00\x02\x00\x01' (total 10)
>             crc = 1648381800

There's the same amount of data, but it's different. Let's check if it decompresses to the same image data:

1
2
3
4
5
6
>>> import zlib
>>> zlib.decompress(b'\x08\x1dc`\x00\x00\x00\x02\x00\x01')
b'\x00\x00'
>>> zlib.decompress(b'\x08[c`\x00\x00\x00\x02\x00\x01')
b'\x00\x00'
>>>

Yep, this means that pixel_alt1.png is the exact same image with the exact same size, but won't be deduplicated when uploading it to Google Photos since the compressed data is different.

Final touches

Now that we have 2 different tiny images, we can upload them to Google Photos and put them in an album so they can be pulled down by the Chromecast. Something to note is that you may have to mark the images as favorites to get them to be displayed. There seems to be some sort of AI-fueled "we know better than you" algorithm that initially refused to display my images until I starred them.

Now just set your ambient mode to display the album with your images in it (or your favorites album), set the slideshow speed to its maximum value (change image every 10 mins), and you're done.


Recovering data off a bootlooping Nexus 5

The situation

The Nexus 5 that I've had for almost 5 years started bootlooping repeatedly.

I've replaced/repaired multiple parts of it over the years but lately it had been more flaky than usual. For example:

  • Sometimes when booting it would show a "Firmware update in progress, don't disconnect your computer" message, even though there was nothing connected to the USB port.
  • It would randomly freeze and soft reboot when using it about once a week.
  • When propping it up on a book or something to angle the screen towards me, the screen would sometimes turn off and on (as it turns out, this was a warning sign)

I've been ready to replace it for a while, but couldn't justify it while this one was perfectly (ok, mostly) functional. That changed today when I tried to turn it on and it started bootlooping.

So buy a new phone and move on, right? Right, except I committed the cardinal sin of living in the digital age - not having complete backups. Yeah, yeah, I know.

I got most of it. I'd been using Syncthing to automatically back up photos, videos, and other files to my home server every night so they were all good. The problem was that I had been using FreeOTP-export to back up my 2FA secrets manually and the latest backup was missing a bunch of logins.

So I needed to somehow get into my non-booting phone and pull the data off it. At least because I was replacing it, all destructive options were on the table.

Diagnosis

The first step was seeing if other people had this problem. Some searching revealed that it was most likely the power button gone bad and being stuck in the pressed position.

To confirm this, I rapidly hammered the power button on a hard surface while booting, hoping that the jarring would un-stick it and let it boot. This sort of worked in that it would boot, but stopping at any point would result it it powering off again. It was also extremely difficult to tap it consistently enough to keep the phone on for long enough to pull any data off it.

The issue I mentioned earlier where propping the phone up made the screen turn on and off now made sense. I'm guessing this was causing a slight flexing of the power button switch, causing it to close and trigger. Over time this must've permanently bent something so it stayed closed, causing the bootloop.

Now that I had pretty much confirmed that it was something physically wrong with the power button circuitry, I messaged my friend Mike. When it comes to electronics, he's definitely more experienced than me. Plus, he lets me borrow his tools :)

The "fix"

The next day Mike came over with his soldering iron and we started brainstorming.

The plan of attack was to just take the power button off the board entirely. It can't always be pressed down if it's not on the board right?

In preparation for this, I wanted the phone to automatically boot when it was plugged into a charger so I wouldn't have to manually short the pins on the board. Fortunately this can be done with a fastboot command: fastboot oem off-mode-charge 0 (basically: don't allow charging while off, therefore turn on when charging).

After desoldering the power button from the main board, it was still bootlooping. Not good. I went back and cleaned up the solder to make absolutely sure that the power button signal pins weren't connected in any way. Still bootlooping when powered on. It would get to the bootloader and stay there, meaning the power button wasn't being pressed anymore, but when launching to either recovery or the main OS, it would immediately restart.

Looked into dumping data from the bootloader - impossible.

Reflashed the boot and recovery partitions - same thing.

Tried booting into recovery using fastboot boot <recovery-image> - bootloop.

sounds like it's time to cry

-- Someone on Freenode's #lineageos-dev channel after I explained the situation

Thankfully, it was not. Right after that, someone else asked if I had reconnected the battery. I had not.

Turns out that a working battery is required to boot the phone, even when it's plugged in. I had taken the battery out to desolder the power button and never put it back in since the phone seemed to boot fine without it. Whoops.

After plugging the battery into the board and booting the phone, it launched the main OS without any issues. Huge relief.

Recovering the data

With the phone booted up normally I used adb (running as root) to pull the 2FA codes and other important things that I knew I needed over to my laptop.

I really don't trust myself to remember everything so I booted the phone into recovery mode and pulled a complete backup of /data/data, /data/app, and /storage/sdcard (not actually an sdcard) to my laptop as well.

To make absolutely sure I didn't miss anything, I also pulled a raw image of the entire flash memory (disk-based encryption was not enabled) using adb pull /dev/block/mmcblk0 mmcblk0.img. Everything I need should be in the normal backups, but if not, I can always go spelunking through that image.

Lessons learned

  • If it's important, back it up automatically. If it's not automatic, at some point it will be missed.
  • Make sure you have the ability to get root access on every device you own before you need it - in this case I wouldn't've been able to pull the 2FA codes or do full backups without it.

Future plans

For the Nexus 5, I'm planning on either buying a replacement power button or maybe just soldering some wires to the exposed pads and snaking them out of the phone to an external button if I can't find one. The phone can then continue to be used as an app development testbed, a Chromecast remote, or as a basic emulation console until it dies for real. In theory I could keep using it as a phone too, but at this point I just don't trust it enough.

For my next phone, I've decided on the Xperia XZ1 Compact. It's a smaller phone that's mostly waterproof (IP68), has a fast SoC (Snapdragon 835), a headphone jack, SD card support, and great battery life. I have high hopes for it. Also, as evidenced by this post, having root access to the OS is pretty critical at times so I'll be flashing LineageOS on it ASAP.


Password recovery from an Alcatel-Lucent Cellpipe 7130

Background

In my current rental situation, the landlord provides internet included with the rental. Since it's fast enough and has enough bandwidth this isn't an issue at all. The only problem is that the modem provided by the telco is an ancient Alcatel-Lucent Cellpipe 7130 5VzA2001 modem/router combo. It's running firmware version 1.0.4.4R8-wh, released on 2012-05-08 16:30 (there are no updates, I checked).

Since the Cellpipe only has 4 x 10/100 LAN ports and terrible WiFi performance, I would much prefer to use my own equipment to perform the routing and just use the Cellpipe 7130 as a WAN gateway. Unfortunately, for some reason, there is no way to turn off the routing aspect of the Cellpipe and just use it as a modem (aka bridge mode). There is also no way to turn off DHCP functionality on it.

My current hacky solution to these problems is to let my router get an IP from the modem/router via DHCP, then set that IP as the DMZ host on the Cellpipe. This effectively forwards all TCP and UDP ports to the router, making it seem like it's the boundary device for the network. Luckily, my router always seems to request the same IP no matter what so this continues to work even if both devices are power cycled.

Since this is not an ideal situation, I'd like to replace the Cellpipe with a more performant modem without any of the routing overhead. To do this, I just need to port the configuration details from the Cellpipe (like the username and password for the upstream PPPoE connection) over to a new modem. Unfortunately, there's nothing in the web interface that will allow me to see the password and there's no option to do a configuration backup. I also can't just call up the telco since it's the landlord's account.

This means we're stuck, right?

Digging into the Cellpipe

Doing a quick CVE search for the Cellpipe only turns up CVE-2015-4586 (a CSRF vulnerability) and CVE-2015-4587 (an XSS vulnerability), both of which aren't useful in this case. Oh well.

Seeing as the Cellpipe 7130 manual(PDF) mentions various functionality that my device doesn't seem have, my hypothesis is that there might be a configuration backup/restore function somewhere, just not exposed in the UI. With that in mind, I went trawling through the HTML and JavaScript files the web UI served up. I found:

The color 'red' is commented out and redefined as white. This suggests that they could be hiding error messages by just making them the same color as the background:

1
2
//var red    ='#FF0000';
var red    ='#FFFFFF';

Debugging in production builds with commented out alert statements:

1
2
//alert(isRouter);
//alert(isAPmode);

Various comments indicating lack of source control:

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
//Jamie hide 20111109
/*if(menuItem=='HPNA')
{
    printMenuItem('hpna.html', 'HPNA', white, darkBlue);
}else{
    printMenuItem('hpna.html', 'HPNA', black, blue);
}
*/
1
2
//fanny add 2011/02/22
printMenuItem('wifi_statistics.html', 'WLAN Statistics ', black, white);
1
2
3
4
5
<!-- jonathan 2004.04.07    Begin  -->
<form name="logoutForm" method="post">
    <input type="hidden" name="logoutMsg">
</form>
<!-- jonathan 2004.04.07    End  -->

These all seem to allude to shoddy release processes, meaning that it's highly likely that per-model customizations were rushed UI-level hack jobs on top of the current release and not maintained branches where actual functionality was changed.

Since a configuration backup will include the PPPoE username and password, let's do a search for "config". Sure enough:

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
printMenuSection('util_main.html', 'Utilities', white);
printMenuItem('lang_set.html', 'Language Setting', black,white);
printMenuItem('util_reboot.html', 'Reboot Gateway', black,white);
//printMenuItem('util_reservice.html', 'Restart Service', black,white);
printMenuItem('util_factory.html', 'Restore Factory Defaults',black, white);
//printMenuItem('util_cfgstore.html', 'Configuration Store', black,white);
//printMenuItem('util_cfgrestore.html', 'Configuration Restore', black,white);
printMenuItem('util_webfirmware.html', 'Web Firmware Upload', black,white);//Jamie add back 20111109

Visiting http://<router_ip>/util_cfgstore.html shows a nice "Store" button that downloads a text file containing 771(!) key/value pairs, including the username and password for the PPPoE connection. Success!

Future plans

There are a ton of other options in the downloaded config file, some of which look like they enable bridge mode. However, flipping those settings on and applying the new config using http://<router_ip>/util_cfgrestore.html didn't seem to change anything. I'm going to keep messing with it while I look into sourcing a better modem to use my newfound credentials with.

Longer-term, the plan is to transition to a dedicated modem that provides WAN access to a low-power computer running pfSense that handles firewall and routing duties. From there, an unmanaged switch (possibly injecting PoE) can provide access for enough dumb wireless APs to bathe the house in WiFi, as well as wired hookups for the devices that don't move around too much or need the throughput. For now though, I'll settle for replacing the modem.

© Carey Metcalfe. Built using Pelican. Theme is subtle by Carey Metcalfe. Based on svbhack by Giulio Fidente.